Best Toaster Oven for Frozen Pizza 2021

Around the world, Pizza comes in many forms, shapes and sizes. In some cases, it can even be the cause of fights. Ask a genuine Sicilian to review a Chicago Pizza in the presence of a Chicago native, and the comments may lead to a fistfight.

Then there’s the debate as to what can actually go on a Pizza. Your Hawaiian may have pineapple on it, but that doesn’t mean it belongs there! We’re not going to adjudicate that debate either way.

What we are going to do is help you on your quest to find the best toaster oven for frozen Pizza. After a long day, throwing a pizza in the oven and eating it 15 minutes later is a comfort. So read on.

List Of Toaster Oven for Frozen Pizza

  1. Calphalon Quartz Heat Countertop Toaster Oven
  2. KitchenAid KCO211DM
  3. Tovala Gen 1 Smart Steam Oven
  4. Toshiba AC25CEW-BS
  5. Cuisinart TOB-260N1
  6. Ninja SP101 Foodi
  7. Breville BOV900BSS
  8. Black & Decker CTO6335S
  9. Cuisinart TOA-60
  10. Breville BOV650XL

Comparison Chart of Top 10 Toaster Oven for Frozen Pizza

IMAGE PRODUCT  
our Top Pick
Calphalon Quartz Heat Countertop Toaster Oven
  • Size: 12 inch Pizza
  • Functions: Bake, Pizza, Broil, Toast, Bagel, Roast, Defrost, Warm, Reheat, Cookies, Dehydrate
  • Display: LCD
  • Rack Positions: 2
KitchenAid KCO211DM
  • Size: 12 inch Pizza
  • Functions: Bake, Broil, Toast, Warm, Reheat, Bagel, Pizza, Cookies, Roast, Frozen
  • Display: Digital
  • Rack Positions: 2
Tovala Gen 1 Smart Steam Oven
  • Size: 12 inch Pizza
  • Functions: Steam, Bake, Broil, Toast, Reheat
  • Connects through mobile App
Toshiba AC25CEW-BS
  • Size: 12-inch Pizza
  • Functions: Toast, Bake, Broil, Pizza, Cookies, Defrost, Reheat, Rotisserie, Keep Warm, Convection
  • Rack Positions: 2
  • Display: LCD
Cuisinart TOB-260N1
  • Size: 13-inch Pizza
  • Functions: Toast, Bagel, Waffle, Keep Warm, Bake, Broil, Roast, Leftovers, Sandwich, Defrost, Pizza
  • Rack Positions: 2
Ninja SP101 Foodi
  • Size: 13-inch Pizza
  • Functions: Air Fry, Air Roast, Air Broil, Dehydrate, Bagel, Bake, Toast
  • Power: 1800 Watts
Breville BOV900BSS
  • Size: 12-inch Pizza
  • Functions: Toast, Bagel, Broil, Bake, Roast, Warm, Pizza, Proof, AirFry, Reheat, Cookies, Slow Cook, Dehydrate
  • Display: LCD
  • Power: 1800 Watts
Black & Decker CTO6335S
  • Size: 12-inch Pizza
  • Functions: Bake, Broil, Toast, Bagel, Pizza, Frozen, Snacks, Potatoes, Cookies
  • Display: Digital
  • Rack Positions: 2
Cuisinart TOA-60
  • Size: 12-inch Pizza
  • Functions: Air Fry, Convection Bake, Convection Broil, Bake, Broil, Warm, Toast
  • Timer: 60-minutes
Breville BOV650XL
  • Size: 12-inch Pizza
  • Functions: Toast, Bagel, Bake, Roast, Broil, Pizza, Cookies, Reheat
  • Display: Back-lit LCD

Best 5 Toaster Ovens for Frozen Pizza Reviews

1. Calphalon Quartz Heat Countertop Toaster Oven

The perfect Pizza requires the perfect oven, and this offering from Calphalon is as close to perfection as you might find.

With its quartz heating element, it produces 40% more heat than the conventional ovens we have been using all our lives. This means you get from turning on the oven to cooking your Pizza faster than ever before. Less waiting time for our food sounds like a winning solution to us.

Overall, this toaster oven has 11 settings. As well as the Pizza setting it also has functions for Bake, Broil, Toast, Bagel, Roast, Defrost, Warm, Reheat, Cookies and Dehydrate.

The fact that this oven has a dedicated Pizza setting shows that Calphalon has really thought about user needs. Not every toaster oven you find has such a range.

Additionally, Calphalon has included a Pizza pan with the accessories, so you know for sure that this toaster oven has been built with Pizza fully in mind.

With two rack positions available there is the option to cook at a higher or lower level, or even change the position of the Pizza during the cooking time. The position of the Pizza in the oven will change the texture of the base if on the lower rack position, or lead to better toasting of the cheese if left on the top position.

Highlighted Features

1. Dedicated pre-set function for pizza cooking
2. Quartz cooking element distributes heat more evenly
3. Spacious interior dimensions allow you to cook a 12″ Pizza

2. KitchenAid KCO211DM

Cook Pizzas from frozen with this fantastic toaster oven from KitchenAid. With its glorious black matte finish, this toaster oven is a stylish addition to any kitchen. But, as well as looking good, it really delivers on the cooking side of things.

This toaster oven has the capacity to cook a single 12-inch Pizza if cooking with a single shelf. However, with two rack positions available, with an extra rack inserted, you can manage two 12-inch Pizzas at a time.

Like the previous toaster oven on the list, this too comes with a dedicated Pizza setting which means your Pizza will get the perfect cook. You turn the dial to Pizza, and for your frozen Pizzas, you will see ‘Frozen 400’ on the digital display. From that point, all you have to do is confirm, and the oven does the rest for you.

Additional pre-set cooking features include bake, broil, toast, warm, reheat, bagel, cookies, roast and frozen. Thus, on those days where you aren’t having Pizza, you have a wealth of alternative options available to you.

Finally, clear-up of dried up, burnt cheese and other cast-offs from your Pizza can be a nightmare to clean. But not with the KitchenAid toaster oven. The crumb tray will catch everything, and can be dishwasher cleaned. The interior is also non-stick and easy to wipe.

Highlighted Features

1. Enough space to cook a 12-inch Pizza
2. Dedicated Pizza function to ensure a perfect cook
3. Non-stick interior easy to clean if cheese spills on to it

3. Tovala Gen 1 Smart Steam Oven

The Tovala Gen 1 Smart Steam Oven is something a bit different to any of the other ovens we have seen in that it seems to have travelled from the future such is the range of tech used in its creation.

This is a smart oven, in that it will connect to your mobile phone through the manufacturer’s App letting you access the perfect settings for the food you are cooking utilising the internet and the wealth of knowledge that can be found on it.

With the bake function, you can easily cook the perfect Pizza, and if you buy your frozen pizzas from companies compatible with the App, you just need to scan the barcode, and the technology does the rest for you.

Convection baking means that the heat the toaster oven produces is distributed evenly throughout the oven, and therefore evenly across your Pizza. Even distribution is essential, especially with a frozen pizza, as you will want to avoid a soggy spot in the middle, combined with burnt crusts because the oven doesn’t spread heat properly.

Other settings on this toaster oven include steam, broil, toast and reheat. If you aren’t a fan of cold Pizza the morning after, then the reheat option will prove to be especially welcome.

Overall, this is a fantastic oven, and perhaps how all toaster ovens will be controlled in the future.

Highlighted Features

1. Connect to your toaster oven with the Tovala App
2. Scan barcodes from certain companies for exact cooking settings
3. Comes with a range of accessories including drain tray and hot pad

4. Toshiba AC25CEW-BS

Toshiba is known for making a range of electronic goods for the house and is perhaps most famous for its televisions. However, their kitchen appliances are well worth your consideration, and that includes this toaster oven.

Another toaster oven with a dedicated pizza setting, this Toshiba appliance will use convection technology to ensure perfectly melted cheese, and a nicely browned crust.

Other functions you get with this toaster oven include: Toast, Bake, Broil, Cookies, Defrost, Reheat, Rotisserie, Keep Warm and Convection.

With these options, we’d be alternating between Pizza and rotisserie chicken on a daily basis, as these are two of the most delicious foods on the planet. We might even get really ambitious and cook rotisserie chicken to put on a pizza.

This toaster ovens extra-large capacity will let you cook a 12-inch pizza. Additionally, it has extra rack positions, so if you purchase a second grill rack, you could conceivably cook two pizzas at a time. Though if doing that you may have to adjust the settings manually.

Clean up is easy – if you aren’t looking at non-stick interiors for your toaster ovens, then you should reconsider. They seriously reduce the amount of cleaning time needed post-cook.

Finally, this oven comes with three easy to turn knobs, making it effortless to use for Pizza lovers of all ages.

Highlighted Features

1. The cool-touch handle makes it less likely to get burnt when cooking Pizza
2. Convection fan ensures even cooking
3. The digital display makes settings and timings easy to read

5. Cuisinart TOB-260N1

We move to Cuisinart for the final toaster oven of this review section. It is very much a case of having saved the best to last.

The first feature to mention is the Dual Cook option which completely changes the way you think about cooking your Pizza.

Think about it, when we order Pizza we don’t just order Pizza. We are provided with a range of additional extras such as garlic bread, chips, chicken wings and other such mouth-watering options.

Well, with this Cuisinart toaster oven you can now cook your Pizza and some sides at the same time. This is because the Dual Cook function allows your oven to operate at one temperature on the top rack, and a different temperature on the bottom rack. It puts you in cooking heaven.

Additional cooking functions with this toaster oven include: Toast, Bagel, Waffle, Keep Warm, Bake, Broil, Roast, Leftovers, Sandwich and Defrost. Pizza is also there.

So vast is the range of options, you could be forgiven for wondering if you could start your own take-away business from the comfort of your own home kitchen.

Another feature we like the look of is the +30 Option. When your cheese doesn’t look quite right, you can press the +30 option adds an extra 30 seconds of toasting time—a nice additional touch to an already fantastic appliance.

Highlighted Features

1. Larger interior lets you cook a 13-inch Pizza
2. 15 cooking functions – many more than other toaster ovens
3. Run two different cooking temperature levels at once

Toaster Oven for Frozen Pizza Buying Guide

Pizza is such fantastic food and to do it justice you require the best toaster oven for frozen Pizza. There are numerous features to look out for if you want a toaster oven that doesn’t disappoint. Here we take a look at those features so that you can make a more informed decision on which toaster oven to purchase.

a. Functions

With this being a look at the best toaster oven options for cooking Pizza, the first thing you should be looking for is the pre-set cooking functions. If ‘Pizza’ isn’t among those options, then how likely is it that the toaster oven has been designed with perfect pizza cooking in mind.

Of course, you won’t exclusively be using your toaster oven for making Pizza, so check out the other functions the toaster oven comes with.

Toaster ovens with a Pizza setting ordinarily have a lot of extras. The best extras we have seen are Rotisserie, Sandwich, Bagel and Waffle. These are all delightful foods that we would quite like during the month.

B. Size

If you’re making Pizza, then you want to have a decent-sized meal. Pizza is just so morish after all. A toaster oven with an interior fitting a 12-inch Pizza is a must.

You’ll find some toaster ovens offer space for two racks. That is an added bonus as it means double the amount of Pizza being cooked.

C. Heating Type

Convection heating is an absolute must for any toaster oven. This is for two reasons. Firstly, a convection oven takes much less time to heat up, and in a world where the majority of us are always pressed for time, that is an incredible bonus.

Secondly, some ovens have this annoying habit of unevenly cooking frozen Pizza. You may have experienced this problem. The crusts of your Pizza are starting to blacken, but the centre of the Pizza is developing a little puddle because it has only just defrosted.

With convection heating, you’ll never have to suffer the disappointment of soggy Pizza ever again. So make sure convection heating is there.

Bottom Line

We are at the end of our look for the best toaster oven for frozen Pizza, and we’re sure you’ll agree it isn’t easy to pick one oven from our list over another.

Ultimately, you’re going to need to make that decision if you’re going make delicious Pizza regularly.

All the oven we looked at will do a great job with frozen Pizza, ensuring they are evenly cooked, and ready to eat in next to no time at all.

Each oven is really easy to clean as well, meaning you don’t have to worry the time saved on cooking will be lost with a load of scrubbing and washing up to do afterwards.

Leave a Reply